New York Mets vs Boston Red Sox

October 1986: World Series Game 6
This was going to be the year to end the misery. After miraculously surviving the LCS against California, the Red Sox are up three games to two in the World Series against the mighty Mets. This time they were going to come out strong, take the lead, and then not fumble it away. Almost everything went according to plan until a guy named Mookie and a guy named Buckner changed history.